Home Food Tutorials 13 Best Substitute For Heavy Cream In Pasta

13 Best Substitute For Heavy Cream In Pasta

by Eduard Anselme
substitute for heavy cream in pasta

If you’ve ever wondered whether there is a substitute for heavy cream in pasta, then this article is for you.

If you’re like me, you love pasta as a main dish. There’s something about the combination of noodles and meat-based sauces that’s comforting. And when it comes to cream sauces, what could be better? The problem is, heavy cream isn’t exactly diet food…or is it? I’ve been exploring alternatives to full-fat cream for months now, and after a lot of trial and error (I’m not afraid of making mistakes), I’ve found an easy substitute that allows me to enjoy my favorite meals while keeping them healthy.

Substitute for heavy cream in pasta

1. Milk

Milk is a good substitute for heavy cream in pasta because it has similar properties. Both milk and heavy cream are high in fat, which makes them ideal for making rich sauces. Both ingredients also have a high protein content, which helps improve the texture of your sauce and make it more filling.


The main difference between milk and heavy cream is that milk has less fat than heavy cream, so it’s not as thick or rich as heavy cream can be. This means that you might need to add more milk than heavy cream to get the same consistency in your sauce, but you’ll still get the same flavor profile.

2. Cream of Coconut (found in the ethnic aisle of your grocery store)

Cream of coconut is a great heavy cream substitute for pasta because both are dairy products, so they have similar consistencies. However, the difference between the two is that heavy cream has a high-fat content (at least 36%), whereas cream of coconut is only about 15% fat. That’s why it’s a good idea to use Half as much cream of coconut as you would heavy cream.

Cream of Coconut
Cream of Coconut

The reason this works so well is because the lower fat content means that it will not overpower your dish with a strong taste or texture. It will also make your pasta lighter and more delicate than if you were using regular heavy cream.

3. Coconut milk, skim milk or soy milk.

Coconut milk, skim milk, and soy milk are all good substitutes for heavy cream in pasta because they have similar nutritional profiles and can be used to create creamy sauces that have a similar consistency to traditional cream sauces.

Coconut milk, skim milk or soy milk.
Coconut milk, skim milk or soy milk.

Coconut milk is made from the meat of a coconut, while skim milk comes from whole milk that has had its fat content reduced by separating it from the rest of the liquid. Soy milk is made by soaking soybeans in water until they’re soft enough to be ground into a powder. Since these items are all derived from plants, they’re all vegan and dairy-free.

All three types of milk are high in protein: coconut milk contains about 1 gram per ounce; skim milk has about 8 grams per cup; and unsweetened soy milk has about 5 grams per cup. They also contain some calcium and vitamin D, which can help prevent osteoporosis. Coconut and soy milks are both low in carbs (about 2 grams per cup), but skim milk contains more carbs than either of them at about 13 grams per cup.

All three types also have a similar consistency: they’re light white liquids with a creamy texture that’s perfect for sauces—in fact, coconut milk is often used as an ingredient in

4. Yogurt (Greek or regular)

Yogurt is a great heavy cream substitute for pasta because it’s thick, creamy, and smooth. The acidity of the yogurt helps it to thicken when mixed with the pasta sauce, giving you a rich sauce without having to use heavy cream.


It’s also healthier than heavy cream, which contains high levels of saturated fat. While yogurt does contain some saturated fat, it has less than half as much as heavy cream does—and most varieties of yogurt have less than 10 grams of sugar per serving.

5. Evaporated milk

Evaporated milk is a good substitute for cream in pasta because it has similar characteristics to the original product. Evaporated milk is a dairy product that is made by removing about 60% of its water content, so it has a higher fat content than regular milk and a lower water content.

Evaporated milk
Evaporated milk

It has the same color as heavy cream but a lighter taste and consistency. It also has less protein than heavy cream and a longer shelf life, making it ideal for dishes like pasta sauce and soups that are cooked ahead of time and stored before serving.

Evaporated milk is also easier to find in grocery stores than heavy cream (though if you don’t have access to either one, you can just use regular milk).

6. Half and Half (you can find it in the milk section)

The main reason that half-and-half is a good substitute for heavy cream is because it has a similar consistency.

The primary difference between the two is that heavy cream has more fat than half-and-half, but since you’re not using much of either ingredient in your pasta dish, there should be little difference in taste or texture. The extra fat content of heavy cream might feel unnecessary if you’re trying to cut back on calories, but this isn’t such a concern when it comes to pasta—especially considering how much cheese and meat are often used as toppings on pasta.

7. Soy creamer or coconut creamer

Soy creamer, coconut creamers, and even almond milk can make great substitutes. This is because they are all low-calorie, low-fat alternatives that can still provide the same creamy texture but with less fat and fewer calories.

Soy creamer
Soy creamer

Soy creamer is a great alternative to heavy cream because it contains no cholesterol or saturated fat. It’s also a good source of vitamins A, D and E.

Coconut creamers are usually made from coconut milk, which is another low-fat option for your pasta sauce. It’s also high in calcium and vitamin C.

Almond milk is another alternative that contains no fat or cholesterol. The only downside is that it does contain some carbs (8g per cup), so if you’re watching your carb intake, this may not be the best option for you.

8. Buttermilk (not the same as sour cream)

Buttermilk is a great substitute for heavy cream because it has a similar fat content but is much lower in calories. To use buttermilk as a substitute for heavy cream in your pasta, simply replace the cream with an equal amount of buttermilk.


When choosing between these two options, keep in mind that both have similar fat contents and are relatively low in calories. Buttermilk has fewer calories than heavy cream, however—it contains about 1/3 fewer calories per serving than heavy cream does. This means that if you’re trying to watch your weight or minimize your calorie intake, buttermilk is a good choice!

9. Milk + Corn Starch

Milk + Corn Starch is a good substitute because it’s creamy, flavorful and neutral-flavored.

Corn Starch
Corn Starch

Heavy cream is a rich and fatty dairy product with a high fat content. It’s thick and buttery, but it also has a lot of calories. So if you’re looking for something to replace it, you need something that will give your sauce the same texture and mouthfeel as heavy cream without adding too many extra calories.

That’s where milk comes in: it adds body and richness to your sauce without sacrificing flavor or texture. And since it’s lower in fat than heavy cream, you can use less of it while still achieving the same effect on your dish.

10. Sour Cream

Sour cream is a good healthy substitute for heavy cream in pasta because it has similar fat content, but it’s lower in calories and cholesterol. It also has a slightly tangier flavor than heavy cream, which some people prefer over the more cloying taste of heavy cream.

Sour Cream
Sour Cream

For those who are lactose intolerant or have other dairy allergies, sour cream is an excellent alternative to heavy cream in pasta like lasagna and Alfredo sauce.

11. Cottage Cheese

Well, the main reason that cottage cheese can be a good heavy cream substitute in pasta is because it has a similar texture and taste. Both are creamy, rich and have a distinctive flavor.

Cottage Cheese
Cottage Cheese

Cottage cheese is also very low in fat, which makes it an excellent choice for those who are watching their weight or trying to eat healthier.

Another reason that cottage cheese is a good substitute for heavy cream in pasta is because it contains less calories than heavy cream does. One cup of heavy cream has about 250 calories, while one cup of cottage cheese only has about 100 calories.

12. Avocado

Avocados make a great heavy cream substitute for pasta because they provide a similar texture, and they can be used in many different types of dishes.


They are also packed with healthy fats and nutrients, which is why they are especially beneficial to your heart.

Avocados are rich in monounsaturated fats, which help lower cholesterol levels while also raising good HDL cholesterol levels in the blood. This makes them great for people who have high cholesterol or are at risk of developing heart disease.

13. Cashew Cream

Cashew cream is a great heavy cream substitute for pasta because it has a similar consistency and flavor but is lower in calories and fat. It also has a similar nutritional profile to heavy cream but has more than twice the vitamin C content.

 Cashew Cream
Cashew Cream

Cashew cream is also easy to make at home—just soak raw cashews overnight, blend them with water until smooth and creamy, and then strain through a cheesecloth.

You can use cashew cream in recipes that call for heavy cream or sour cream. It’s especially good with pasta dishes like Carbonara or Baked Ziti!


What can I use instead of cream in pasta sauce?

You can use milk instead of cream in pasta sauce. Milk has a similar consistency to cream, and it won’t thin out the sauce too much if you use it instead.

dairy-free substitute for heavy cream in pasta

If you’re looking for a dairy-free substitute for heavy cream to use in your pasta recipes, we’ve got you covered!

Try using coconut milk instead. It’s especially good if you want a thicker sauce. You can also use soy creamer or almond milk if you prefer not to use coconut milk.


Heavy cream is traditionally used in making pasta and sauces, but if you are watching your weight or have a smaller budget, there is a great substitute for heavy cream in pasta: Milk. Cream can be higher in calories than milk, but with a few substitutions, you can still add flavor to your pasta and sauce without adding fat.

Other Ingredients Substitutes:

You may also like

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.